Googled Knowledge vs Real Know how

Your new project has just been approved, and now you need to staff it.

Whether you go to HR to get resumes of potential team members, or post available team positions on LinkedIn or Career Builder, your problem is the same. Every resume you sift through seems to have all of the project ‘buzz words.’  Which resume reflects real project expertise, versus “Googled” expertise?

I am seeing a disconcerting pattern in today’s staffing. I look at someone’s resume for a position on a project and it looks like they have done everything and know everything—yet when I count up the years of experience it doesn’t add up.

How can that be?

Here’s how:  Job seekers are advised by various recruiting experts and websites to “fill your resume with the right buzz words to get you noticed” and advise that the buzz words you choose should “come directly from the job description.”  http://chicago.cbslocal.com/2010/12/14/fill-your-resume-with-the-right-buzz-words/

Although these experts caution job seekers to use the words only if you have the expertise, I can tell you that it is not always the case, at least on project management resumes I’ve seen. And it gets worse. “CareerBuilder.com” has a list of universal keywords to “help you attract attention.” OK-In fairness to job seekers, I realize that their resume will be read first by an applicant tracking system (ATS) and if it doesn’t match target key words it will never be reach a human.  (Who decided that a computer scanning program was the best way to screen applicants???)

This makes it really tough for those of us who are trying to staff with real expertise and not over inflated resumes.  After all, anyone can Google key words to review wiki definitions, read examples, and quickly obtain surface level knowledge of a topic. While definitions, facts, and key factors may be Googled, a good project manager can conduct behavioral interviews that focus on how the interviewee solved a particular problem, reacted to a crisis situation, and applied PMBoK knowledge in real life. Furthermore, making simulated scenarios, and exercises such as “fix the project schedule” or “how would you crash this schedule?”, will quickly let you ferret out real knowledge from Googled knowledge.

I dont think that these HR and recruiting firms have it right – in fact I think they are poluting the water with bloated resumes because of the way they use automated systems rather than actual interviews.  I guess they are getting ready for hiring robots rather than humans!

What other techniques do you use to ensure that the staff you bring onto your projects can do the real work of project management?

 

What if Project Managers had Mandatory Counseling?

I was watching a police drama show on TV as background noise the other night and someone in charge was telling an officer, “What you just experienced is stressful and carries potential long term emotional impact. You need to schedule an appointment with the department shrink to help you deal with your feelings.”

Hmmm, I said to myself. Project management can be very stressful at times. I have had nightmares about unanticipated problems, start-up failures, and integration debacles. However, I do not remember anyone suggesting I get counseling support to deal with my feelings.

So I wandered around in my head and constructed this possible dialogue between a PM and a therapist.

Good morning, Bruce. Have a seat. I understand you are a project manager and you may be experiencing some job-related stress.
Yeah, I guess so.
Tell me about your job. What does a project manager do?
(Oh, good grief!) I manage a small group of very talented people trying to build software with too few resources, too little time and unrealistic expectations.
What kinds of tasks does a project manager do?
I plan, manage risks, develop schedules, handle quality control, deal with stakeholders, report to senior management, create budgets, negotiate with other project managers, write proposals, develop presentations, travel — a lot of travel — I write reports, manage personality conflicts …
Excuse me for interrupting, Bruce. But, are all of those tasks necessary for project management?
And then some. I haven’t even mentioned keeping up with new technologies, estimating, evaluating …
Ok. I think I get the idea. You have many different tasks to do. How does that make you feel?
Feel? I don’t understand the question. This is not about feelings. This is my job.
Are you anxious about work? Have trouble sleeping? Find yourself thinking about work even when you are not there?
Yeah (duh!)
Do you take me-time to relax and refresh? Like reading a book or taking long weekends? Or, just sitting quietly? Like me, even though I am talking with you, I am sitting in a comfortable chair and I can look out the window at the flowers and birds — give my mind a beauty break.
Okay
For example, don’t you feel more relaxed after you returned to work from a long vacation?
I don’t remember. Right after I got back from my last vacation two years ago, we had a system meltdown. All I could think was that maybe if I had stayed there, I could have prevented it.
You seem to have an overly developed sense of responsibility. Perhaps you need to cut yourself some slack.
(yeah, and lose my job) Being responsible is part of the job.
Sounds like you do not have much personal time. Taking time for yourself helps reduce stress and anxiety. You can actually do a more effective job when you are not stressed out. Let’s talk about your work environment. What problems at work create the greatest anxiety for you?
I guess people problems. Like when two of my team members developed a personal relationship that then went south. Now, they won’t work together and if they are in the same room, one of them shouts bad things at the other.
Can you remove one of them from the team?
No I have to work around it. We are already short-handed. I cannot afford to lose either one.
How does that make you feel?
(Is there a polite way to say this …) Frustrated, I guess.
Anything else?
Well, there’s the paperwork and useless meetings and …
Sorry to interrupt again, but I see that we are out of time. I appreciate your coming in, Bruce. We will need to meet again next year to see how things are going. Remember, the minefields of life never go away; we just get better at navigating them (stolen from “Necessary Roughness”).I hope our session helped you see the importance of relaxing and reducing stress in your life.
Well that was a fun — and relaxing — trip through my imagination.

Guess I will get back to work, now – I have at least 20 emails waiting on me to solve problems!

The Lazy Project Manager's Blog

The Home of Productive Laziness Thoughts

ProjectManagement.com

Thoughts, experience, tips and tricks on issues affecting managers and project management

A Girl's Guide to Project Management

Project Management musings for one and all

LeadingAnswers: Leadership and Agile Project Management Blog

Thoughts, experience, tips and tricks on issues affecting managers and project management

Project Management Hut

Thoughts, experience, tips and tricks on issues affecting managers and project management

Herding Cats

Thoughts, experience, tips and tricks on issues affecting managers and project management

beyondcenter

Pushing the Edges Out ...

projectxpert

Just another WordPress.com site